Abstract
When a person enters a lift - whether to load it, unload it or just to travel in it - the
question is whether they are entitled to believe that it offers an acceptable level of safety. Given that
the function of the lift, whether manufactured to The Lift Directive or The Machinery Directive, is
the same (i.e. to move goods from one level to another), would it not be reasonable to expect that
the levels of safety would be the same? This paper will look at the different requirements against
uncontrolled movement in the downward direction and will discuss the risks with reduced levels of
protection, as well as the implications for persons in the car, including those who have to enter the
car to maintain the said lift.